Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.7 out of 5, 3,176 ratings on Amazon

#86 of 2,629 all-time

The Power Broker

Robert Caro

50 people recommended it in 25 threads, 2009–2025.

What people on Hacker News said

schlagetown
The Power Broker, by Robert Caro - unbeatably rich and compelling look at how power and politics actually work, for better (power gets things done) and for worse (power blinds and corrupts)

on HN, 2017

russnewcomer
The Power Broker by Robert Caro. This one actually took me about 6 months between reading and Audible, because it is in some ways too detailed, but the naked use of power for maintaining power for a singular vision is illuminating. Even in an antagonistic biography, Moses leaps off the page as a bright, energetic, flawed human.

on HN, 2022

Nav_Panel
I adore this book. It also took me 6 months to read. I think about it often while wandering around the city, imagining the areas before and after Moses' steel-and-concrete hand, imagining the old neighborhoods, trying to envision what could be next, what could have been, what could be.

on HN, 2017

kens
I agree on The Power Broker; it is kind of amazing and changed my view of New York City. To summarize, Robert Moses leveraged a parks commission position to reshape New York City how he wanted it: from bridges and expressways and urban renewal to the Lincoln Center and United Nations buildings.

on HN, 2017

Spooky23
Nobody has ever captured the nature of power on an individual level to the depth and breadth that Caro did on this book. (except perhaps his epic treatment of Lyndon Johnson)

on HN, 2017

jamestimmins
The Power Broker - About Robert Moses, the most powerful city planner in New York from the 1930s to the 1960s. Great if you're interested in city planning, how people gain and exercise power, and the real politik of government.

on HN, 2017

RoboTeddy
'The Power Broker' by Robert Caro is ostensibly a biography, but it's actually about how power works. The protagonist starts out employing idealistic methods, but falls flat on his face, and comes to delight in any means of achievement.

on HN, 2019

pjmorris
How Moses acquired the power (genius, legislation, money and, through them, influence) to physically reshape New York City and State seems pretty relevant to understanding how things work today.

on HN, 2025

And on Amazon

Fantastic biography. Worth the effort.

The Power Broker is a book I assume that sits on quite a few reading lists, but rarely actually gets read. Coming in at 1,162 pages, 1,300+ when including notes and index, it’s easy to understand why. It’s a monster. But anyone who is brave enough to commit to reading it will be rewarded for doing so. Robert Caro has written a masterpiece. The Power Broker is a biography of Robert Moses, the transformative city planner of New York during the mid-1900s, who was obsessed with one thing: power. Robert Moses accomplished things that even some U.S. presidents can only dream of, all while never being elected to public office. …

Daniel · verified purchase · 5/5

A Remarkable Book

Robert Caro has managed to create an incredible insight into Robert Moses, history and complexities. The scope of the book is so broad, it incorporates politics, legislation, engineering, history. Moses involvement and contribution to the shaping of New York City in New York State and Long Island is almost too much to comprehend and grasp. The books development of who he was carries through through his whole life and the history he lived through and shaped. It’s wonderfully well written and remarkably well researched, and fascinating.

Avid Reader · verified purchase · 5/5

Excellent in every way and well worth the price, reading time, and your attention

Here we have one of the best books I have ever read and I, a bookworm, have read thousands. The writing is clear, crisp, and holds interest throughout the 1,167 pages. The facts of the recent history of New York City and the abuse of power, waste of public money, back biting, petty jealousies and, in short, the red thread of life, overwhelmingly support Caro’s conclusion that trusting one man, Moses in this case, with so much power leads to corruption and chaos. My neighbor who called my attention to this great book said the abuses of power mirror almost exactly what we are presently seeing at the national level. I agree. …

Bernard M. Patten · verified purchase · 5/5

Where it comes up