Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.6 out of 5, 7,045 ratings on Amazon

#104 of 2,629 all-time

Ishmael

Daniel Quinn

44 people recommended it in 22 threads, 2009–2026.

1 commenter pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.

What people on Hacker News said

nkrisc
That book made me realize that all the truths everyone "just knows" and takes for granted aren't necessarily truths. They're beliefs, or myths.

on HN, 2019

ianai
Quinn uses a hypothetical conversation between a gorilla and a person to highlight the fundamental us versus them approach humans take with the rest of earth.

on HN, 2020

neonnoodle
However, it prompted me to pursue a degree in bioanthropology. Most of the enthographic literature is consistent with the hypothesis that people don't willingly join civilization (city-based, hierarchical societies) when given the choice.

on HN, 2017

uoaei
Its main lesson is that culture tells us there is only one way for civilization to act in the world and that we cannot examine this imposition -- because of the "fish asks 'what's water?'" situation we're in -- until we really unpack what narratives are driving people to act and think in the ways they do.

on HN, 2023

vector_spaces
The most powerful lesson I learned here is what anthropologists call cultural relativism. This book also taught me that everyone is under the influence of Mother Culture and her stories.

on HN, 2020

nkrisc
His biases are clear, but even if you disagree with him, looking past those there is still the very important lesson that much of what we take for granted as true about the world is really not much more than shared mythology, not some objective, universal truth.

on HN, 2022

justinhj
Ishmael is one about an intelligent ape that explains the natural world to a guy in socratic dialogue style.

on HN, 2018

And on Amazon

A Mind-expanding Book

I just finished reading Daniel Quinn's Ishmael this morning, for the third or fourth time. Prior to my first reading, in 1994, I had already learned a good deal about the problems of agriculture and civilization, so Ishmael didn't make my head explode. But when you're wandering far out on the wild frontier, and thinking far outside the box, it's reassuring to discover others on the same path. "Hey! I'm not crazy!" That's always a thrill. Every time I read the book, I'm impressed by the depth of Quinn's knowledge and thinking. It's jam-packed with descriptions of many serious problems, yet it succeeds at remaining an inspiring piece of work. …

Richard Reese (author of Understanding Sustainability) · verified purchase · 5/5

Excellent Use of the Socratic Dialogue

Ishmael is a philosophical novel written by Daniel Quinn that was published in 1992. The story begins with a newspaper ad: "Teacher seeks pupil. Must have an earnest desire to save the world. Apply in person." The unnamed narrator decides to check it out and finds himself in a room with a telepathically-communicating gorilla named Ishmael. The basic plot of the book involves a Socratic dialogue between Ishmael and the narrator focusing on "how things came to be this way" for humankind. …

David Wilder · verified purchase · 5/5

Philosophical but also…weird.

I had to read this for my ethics class—overall I liked the ideas presented, although the story itself was not the greatest read.

grimalkin · verified purchase · 4/5

Where it comes up