I Am a Strange Loop
Douglas Hofstadter
33 people recommended it in 24 threads, 2009–2024.
3 commenters pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.
What people on Hacker News said
I think that even if you disagree with him, it's worth reading because there are so many things you can take away from this book. For example, he talks about his wife's death, and ties that into his theory of mind and explains the unstated purposes of why we have funerals/wakes for people.
The things that lead him to thinking critically about consciousness because of his disabled sister I found to be something that changed not only how I interacted with people that were differently abled, but also changed how I saw my own disabilities.
Regardless of what you think about what Hofstadter proposes, I think his contribution to critical exploration of the consciousness is artful and invaluable. I think it's fun, compassionate, and beautiful, and it really changed how I see myself and my environment.
The book is somewhat life changing, in the questions that it asks. You might find yourself thinking about things differently, such as what it is to be conscious, can we ever achieve artificial intelligence, is there such a thing as fate, how was J.S. Bach able to produce such stunning compositions, etc.
Both are excellent reads, but I'd definitely agree IaaSL is far more approachable and a better use of your time.
It explores an idea of consciousness as being a side effect over neurological loops becoming recursive. It also gets into the idea that your conscious mind can partially blend into another's.
But if you want to know more about how self-reference actually leads to consciousness and more about Hofstadter the person I recommend it.
And on Amazon
Why do we build societies? What is consciousness?
I Am a Strangel Loop is a scientific discussion on the immortality of the soul. Or perhaps it's a poetic discourse on the physiology of the brain. It floats between a diverse array of ideas that readers will either find fascinating or infuriating. This book admittedly starts out slow, as many readers have pointed out, so I recommend to start reading on pg. 147, and referring to Index the as needed. For the mathematically inclined, pgs. 125-142 give an amazingly good explanation of Godel's Incompleteness Theorem. But pg. 147 is where the big picture ideas that I cared most about really started to start flowing. …
Thomas P. Burwell · verified purchase · 5/5
Excellent
This is a magnificently constructed exploration of consciousness as a phenomenon. Hofstadter approaches the topic from a symbolic perspective, as opposed to a psychological or physiological one. Through endless analogies and eloquent description, he eases the reader into the idea that there's nothing magic or "special" about consciousness, and that it is essentially an illusion that arises from sufficiently complex systems. To some, this conclusion might sound outrageous (or at least unpalatable). But take my word for it... …
Andrew Matteson · verified purchase · 5/5
Recursion and the Over-Unification of the Self
I Am a Strange Loop is often described as a theory of consciousness. It is more accurate to say that it changes how we look at the self. Douglas Hofstadter does not defend a soul or a hidden mental substance. His proposal is simpler: the “I” is a pattern. More specifically, it is a self-referential pattern — what he calls a strange loop. When a system can represent itself, feed that representation back into its own activity, and stabilize the cycle, a strange loop forms. Consciousness, in this view, is identified with such stabilized self-reference. It is what self-reference feels like from the inside. …
KN · verified purchase · 4/5
Where it comes up
- Gödel, Escher, Bach is the most influential book in my life (2022) 2024 · 3 recommendations
- Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books programmers should read?’ 2019 · 3 recommendations
- Ask HN: What books have made the biggest impact on your mental models? 2017 · 3 recommendations
- Ask HN: Mind bending books to read and never be the same as before? 2020 · 2 recommendations
- Ask HN: What books changed the way you think about almost everything? 2019 · 2 recommendations
- Ask HN: Which book are you reading these days? 2015 · 2 recommendations
- Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read? 2024 · 1 recommendation
- Books I loved reading this year 2021 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: What are the best unknown books you have read? 2020 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: Best books you read in the past decade? 2019 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: Books you plan to read in 2020? 2019 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: Favorite nonfiction books of 2018? 2018 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: What was the one book that you read and it actually changed your life? 2018 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: What are your favorite non-fiction books of all time? 2018 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: 2018 Summer Reading List? 2018 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: Which books have made you introspect? 2018 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: What books are you reading? 2017 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: Books you wish you had read earlier? 2017 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: What book have you given as a gift? 2016 · 1 recommendation
- Ask HN: What books are you reading? 2015 · 1 recommendation
