Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.3 out of 5, 2,393 ratings on Amazon

#101 of 2,629 all-time

Diaspora

Greg Egan

45 people recommended it in 17 threads, 2008–2024.

2 commenters pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.

What people on Hacker News said

bemmu
In Diaspora consciousness is just a piece of software. Since this software can be run at a much higher speed than wetware can, each moment of real time seems much longer to the uploaded. But when they want to, for example when waiting for an interstellar trip to complete, they can "skip forward" and let the brain emulator run them at a much slower pace to make the trips more bareable.

on HN, 2015

chairmanwow1
He also never thinks small. I thought I knew "the point" of Diaspora about 6 or 7 times, but then he just "zoomed out" and made the last point look small and trivial by comparison.

on HN, 2020

pierrec
It's an incredibly well thought out extrapolation of the future of the human race, much less phantasmagorical and much more grounded in science than pretty much every other SF I know of, while still going off into mind-bending tangents.

on HN, 2015

prepend
I think the opening of that book stuck in my head as that is how digital beings and digital identity WILL BE DONE. It makes so much sense to me.

on HN, 2023

adamch
Brilliant sci-fi where computer science concepts like cellular automata, computation complexity etc are major plot points. Starts with a highly detailed explanation of AI personality creation. Super geeky and a brilliant plot.

on HN, 2018

psykotic
If you're a programmer, Permutation City would be my recommendation. If you're more mathematically inclined, Diaspora is a good choice. Just so you know what kind of book you'd be in for, the first chapter of Diaspora has a proof outline of the Gauss-Bonnet theorem.

on HN, 2011

aoeuid
Reading Permutation City left me in a dazzled state for days because of the sheer number of reality-altering concepts it throws at you in such a short span.

on HN, 2008

philh
Most of the characters are sentient software, and it explores some of the implications of being able to fork oneself, or rewrite your software. On top of that the physics is, to the best of my mildly-educated knowledge, an extension of General Relativity consistent with what we already know; and part of it takes place in a six-dimensional spacetime.

on HN, 2012

And on Amazon

Incredible mind-blowing hard sci-fi

What an incredible book. I was intimidated at first and a little turned off by some of the reviews, but I am so glad I read this book as it is possibly my favorite sci-fi book ever. Yes, it is challenging and some of it I didn't understand, but its written in a way that you don't have to understand all of it to understand the story. It is probably necessary to have some basic knowledge of modern cosmological theories and AI speculation, and yes you will have to pay attention and think about some things, but that's part of the great pleasure of reading this book. …

ethios4 · verified purchase · 5/5

Full of Fascinating Ideas, but Flawed

I'm sometimes not sure exactly how to react to the works of Greg Egan. Diaspora, while a good book, generated the same react as other Egan I've read. Sometimes his works seem brilliant. At other times, Egan seems too clever for his good, intent on showing off lots of details about new ideas. Sometimes the work moves right along. At others, it stops with the old hack of "tell me again professor exactly how wormholes work." (This one really happens in Diaspora.) Sometimes the novels seems driven by an interesting story. …

Kindle Customer · verified purchase · 4/5

The best "Futurism as Fiction" book I can recall reading

As other reviewers have noted, this book is full of fascinating ideas. Is the "information dump" to which reviewer Jim Mann refers a bit much at times? Perhaps. Is the story at times slightly contrived around an idea? Probably(I'd say the best example of this is the end of the story, which gets a bit repetitive and seems to perhaps only be there to showcase the idea that there are infinite dimensions). But, flaws aside, here is why I cannot give this book less than 5 stars: The fascinating ideas are REALLY FASCINATING. …

James R · verified purchase · 5/5

Where it comes up