Y Hacker News Books
Buy on Amazon4.5 out of 5, 22,012 ratings on Amazon

#9 of 2,629 all-time

Atlas Shrugged

Ayn Rand

173 people recommended it in 59 threads, 2007–2026.

61 commenters pushed back on it — worth reading the threads.

What people on Hacker News said

mindcrime
It has its issues, but it's absolutely a book everyone should read, whether you agree with Rand's ideology or not. And if you aren't familiar enough to Rand's ideology to know if you agree or not,that's all the more reason to read Atlas Shrugged (or The Fountainhead).

on HN, 2017

aronowb14
completely transformative book for looking at our world, America particularly. Th perspective it gives you may not be in the best, or most human way, but I’ve found no other book that forces you to empathize with capitalism like this one.

on HN, 2020

leobg
Ayn Rands books are really good and revolutionary and one should read them, perhaps even multiple times. But one probably shouldn’t take them as the final answer to the questions of life.

on HN, 2021

chrischattin
"Atlas Shrugged" gets a lot of hate, but it's a phenomenally important book. It was one of those that completely consumed me during the read. I could not put it down – stayed up late, work up early, and rushed home from work to get back to it.

on HN, 2020

alfor
So this book provide some refreshing perspective and a way of thinking that is lost on most people today. That doesn’t mean that it contain all the solutions.

on HN, 2021

jjmarr
Honestly Ayn Rand's sexual politics are more interesting than her economic politics. The books are mostly about masculinity and its definition. The ideal men in her books are immutable flawless beings, and the (good) women learn to define themselves by dating progressively better men.

on HN, 2024

cik
Atlas Shrugged - Ayn Rand. Love her or hate her, she makes you think.

on HN, 2020

And on Amazon

review in contrast

Granted this is a lengthy book. For those that find reading it a chore, then I would highly recommend the audio unabridged version read by Scott Brick produced by Blackstone Audio. The audio reader does such a good job at making the story flow in a beautiful rhythm, almost poetic. He does an amazing job revealing Ms. Rand's vivid descriptions of how her characters feel and what they see allowing the listener live the story not just listen to it. …

Kritter · verified purchase · 5/5

A lot of baggage, but still one of the most relevant works of all time

This is one of them most intriguing works I've read in years and it can provoke vigorous reaction on a variety of levels. There's easily enough meat here to justify considering this one of the most important writing in Western Civilization, but unfortunately, it's weighed down by more than enough baggage to prevent many from seeing it in that light. Even so, the ideas are so powerful, I'll give it five stars and point out flaws only to help you recognize and avoid being distracted by them. For starters, this book is a disaster if viewed purely in novelistic terms. …

Amazon Customer · verified purchase · 5/5

Noteworthy Page Turner

The Objectivists may dislike my review because it criticizes philosophical elements of the novel and progressives may dislike my review because it praises the book as a work of fiction. So go ahead and stamp your forms, sonny, and stop wasting my time I tried to read Atlas Shrugged with a sympathetic eye, which as I understood it put me at a considerable disadvantage. It was worth the effort. This is an outstanding novel. In my mind it is only effective as such, and not as a manifesto. I have to say I was very pleasantly surprised at how engaging and satisfying it was. …

S · verified purchase · 4/5

Where it comes up